'Exterminate all the brutes': Gaza 2009 By Noam Chomsky | January 21, 2009

6 posts / 0 new
Last post
Yibpl
'Exterminate all the brutes': Gaza 2009 By Noam Chomsky | January 21, 2009

...causing vastly disproportionate terror, a doctrine that traces back to the 1950s.

causing disproportionate terror, or "frightfulness" is a tactic which gave be traced back to the Norman Invasion of Britain in 1066, if not earlier.
 

... the latest U.S.-Israeli attack  [The US did not participate in Israel’s actions taken in self-defence]  on helpless Palestinians was launched ...

Mahmoud Zahar, a top Hamas strongman in Gaza promised to "crush" Israeli Defence Forces, he obviously did not consider themselves to be helpless.  Hamas posses Oghab, Fajr-3 / Ra'ad, Grad and WeiShi rockets which they have rained down on Israeli civilians; hardly helpless.  Musheir al-Masri, a Hamas spokesman in the Palestinian Legislative Council, said (Filastin al-‘An website, December 24) that the rockets which had been launched were only the first message and threatened to extend the attacks beyond what had been carried out so far. He guaranteed that Israel would “be hit in a way it had never been before,” and that he was not afraid of Israel.  He obviously did not believe that they were helpless.
 
Only a sanctimonious pseudo-intellectual writing in the comfort and security of  the urban west would describe Hamas led Gaza as being helpless, and vilify Israel’s right to exist and defend itself. Of course, Noam Chomsky is not going to let little things like the facts or the truth get in the way of her anti-semitism.

Catchfire Catchfire's picture

What could you possibly be talkinag about?

First of all, here's the link to the story on rabble's front page.

Secondly, Chomsky is clearly referring to the Palestinean civilians who were, according to Chomsky, explicitly and specifically targeted by the Israeli military machine. That's why they're 'helpless'--whatever illusions you have manufactured for yourself to allow you to believe that the rockets pose any threat to Israel's 'security', 'right to exist' or 'comfort' (whatever that means).

And for crying out loud, Noam Chomsky is a man.

Stargazer

Not to mention Jewish.

Frustrated Mess Frustrated Mess's picture

Quote:
The disregard for life from these terrorists and their supporters is shocking. For example Thomas Friedman, the New York Times columnist, wrote that the purpose of the Israeli attack must be to "inflict a heavy death toll and heavy pain on the Gaza population".

Replace "Gaza" with "western", and that could have been written by al-Qa'ida. Maybe this is the problem: the Israelis are writing their policies by downloading statements from an Islamic Jihad website and just changing the place names. Also, if the Israelis think the Hamas rockets are as lethal as they say, why don't they swap their F-16 fighters and Apachehelicopters for a few of them?

http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/mark-steel/mark-steel-now-weve-all-seen-through-the-israeli-governments-excuses-1452234.html 

Frustrated Mess Frustrated Mess's picture

Quote:
A Palestinian father has claimed that he saw two of his young daughters shot dead and another critically injured by an Israeli soldier who emerged from a stationary tank and opened fire as the family obeyed an order from the Israeli forces to leave their home.

 

Khaled Abed Rabbo said Amal, aged two and Suad, seven, were killed by fire from the soldier's semi-automatic rifle. His third daughter, Samer, four, has been evacuated to intensive care in a Belgian hospital after suffering critical spinal injuries which he said were inflicted in the attack early in Israel's ground offensive.

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/gaza-i-watched-an-israeli-soldier-shoot-dead-my-two-little-girls-1452294.html 

Merowe

'...causing vastly disproportionate terror, a doctrine that traces back to the 1950s.

causing disproportionate terror, or "frightfulness" is a tactic which gave be traced back to the Norman Invasion of Britain in 1066, if not earlier.'

So... Israel is pursuing policies appropriate...to the 11th century?

Ok, I'm with you so far...when do the witch burnings begin?