At those prices, does Apple really need to use sweatshops?

32 posts / 0 new
Last post
Lard Tunderin Jeezus Lard Tunderin Jeezus's picture
At those prices, does Apple really need to use sweatshops?

One Bad Apple

I'm a big fan of Apple products, but I think I'm going to have to start paying a lot more attention as to where individual products are made.

remind remind's picture

Does it really matter where it is made?

Quote:
In any case, don’t expect Apple’s shareholders to have any sympathy. They have recently been calling for Apple’s genius CEO, Steve Jobs, to step down because his ailing health is affecting Apple’s share price. If that’s the way they treat the man at the top, how do they feel about the minions at the bottom?

A clue can be found in the comments section underneath the Christian Science Monitor’s online report on Sun’s death. An Apple shareholder calling himself iphoneinvestor wrote: “I’ll need to pull out a considerable amount of shares if activists and labour rights groups across the nation begin jumping all over this. They may decide to block consumers at the Apple and AT&T stores causing my profits to plummet downhill!”

And this:

Quote:
Well, there are solar-powered media players and phones not made by Apple. But there are no guarantees they don’t contain coltan, a mineral commonly found in laptops, phones and media players, and whose extraction fuels slavery and wars in the Democratic Republic of Congo.

Why do the mining and manufacturing companies feel they have to exploit and abuse their labour? Greed only covers so much.. no?

Why can't they impliment legal mining practises in the DRC?

 

Merowe

 

 

Quote:

Why do the mining and manufacturing companies feel they have to exploit and abuse their labour? Greed only covers so much.. no?

Why can't they impliment legal mining practises in the DRC?

 

 

Decades-long resource wars, for a start.

remind remind's picture

Manufactured wars you mean?

Tommy_Paine

It's too bad our lives depend so much on ipods and cell phones, elst we could do something about it.

remind remind's picture

Glad mine doesn't.

Tommy_Paine

Wink

NorthReport

How could you not approve of Apple now?

 

Heritage Minister approves of CBC iPhone App

 

 

NorthReport

Steve Jobs's new trick: the Apple tablet

Rumours are rife that Steve Jobs is about to unveil a revolutionary touchscreen gadget

 

http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2009/aug/23/apple-tablet-steve-jobs...

Michelle

Hee, Tommy.

You know, Apple just might find themselves lots of investors if they stop using sweatshops - they could market themselves as an ethical company, get onto ethical investment portfolios, get consciously-minded people to buy their products, etc.

Catchfire Catchfire's picture

IPhone plant defends itself after worker suicides

Quote:
Taiwan's Foxconn Technology, a contract maker of the iPhone and other consumer electronics, insisted Wednesday its treatment of workers is world class after a female employee became the company's eighth Chinese worker to commit suicide this year.

"We regret to see the recurrence of such incidents," Foxconn said in statement that came a day after a 24-year-old Foxconn factory worker surnamed Chu killed herself by jumping from her rented apartment in the southern Chinese city of Shenzhen.

Foxconn, the world's largest contract maker of electronics, said that Chu, whose full name was not released, began her employment last August.

The company has attracted wide attention from the Chinese media following a spate of suicides among young Chinese working at its mammoth Shenzhen factory complex, where some 300,000 are employed.

A week ago, a 24-year-old male factory worker surnamed Lu committed suicide by jumping from a building inside the complex.

The most notable Foxconn suicide came last July when 25-year-old Sun Danyong jumped from his high-rise apartment after being interrogated over a missing iPhone prototype.

HeywoodFloyd

Wow. 300k employees at one complex. That's incredible.

Snert Snert's picture

According to WHO, the suicide rate in China is about [url=http://www.who.int/mental_health/prevention/suicide/suiciderates/en/]28 per 100,000.[/url]

 

This factory seems to have a rate of approximately 5 per 100,000.

 

Looks like this factory is less of a hellhole and more of a haven.

Catchfire Catchfire's picture

I'm not sure about your math, Snert, but that's an interesting point. I think the WHO site you link to shows that the suicide rate in China is about 15 per 100 000 (I don't think you should add the two numbers like you did). And since we are only just halfway through May, at this rate the factory will see about 18-20 suicides this year, or 6-7 per 100 000. Still less than half the national average. I wonder why Apple's PR didn't point that out?

Although I'm not sure I'd call a factory housing 300 000 workers (!) a "haven."

Snert Snert's picture

I added the two as I interpreted them as "male suicides" and "female suicides".

Regarding the factory, I accounted for us being about halfway through the year by assuming about twice as many suicides -- 16 -- and then dividing by 3 to account for 300,000 employees.  So if that math is reasonable, this factory has between a fifth and a sixth of the national average.

Based on that, I can only conclude that SWEATSHOPS SAVE LIVES.  :0

writer writer's picture

Manufactured Landscapes helps give a picture of the scale: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x4eLsRUbtBk

Catchfire Catchfire's picture

Another worker death at iPhone firm Foxconn

Quote:
In China a factory worker has died after falling from a high building, the latest in a string of such deaths at the same plant.

The man, who was 19, was employed by Foxconn, a Taiwanese firm also known as Honhai.

The firm makes mobile phones, games consoles and computers for companies like Apple, Hewlett Packard and Sony.

Nine people have died after falling off buildings at the factory this year. Two others were seriously injured.

Police are not saying yet whether this was a suicide attempt, a suspicious death or an accident.

It happened just one day after Foxconn started playing music to workers on the assembly line to try to ease the pressure on them.

E.Tamaran

And Rabble gives away Apple products as prizes. just sayin'

Fidel

Otoh, Canada's economy is a bastion of workplace ethics. And we deal with it by not making anything anymore. The garlic bulbs in my pantry? China.

Catchfire Catchfire's picture

Newly installed nets to prevent workers from jumping to their  deaths are pictured outside a Foxconn building in Longhua, China.

How much did the nets cost?

Quote:
A Taiwanese company that makes most of the world's most popular electronic gadgets is raising salaries for its workers after a spate of suicides.

Taiwan-based Foxconn Technology Group operates one of the largest manufacturing centres in the world, employing more than 400,000 workers in Shenzhen, China.

After reports that more than a dozen of the plant's workers have committed suicide in recent weeks because of poor working conditions, the company announced plans to increase wages by as much as 20 per cent to improve morale.

On Wednesday, Foxconn upgraded that figure to an across the board 30 per cent pay raise.

ennir

How much of that 30% will they take back for yawning on the job or speaking to another worker or any of the insane rules they must work under?

And Rabble gives away Apple products and uses the Royal Bank, wow, I find myself jarred by the incongruity of a "progressive" board supporting those who are not progressive at all.

RosaL

Among other things, Foxconn produces the Mac mini, the iPod, the iPad, and the iPhone for Apple Inc.; Intel-branded motherboards for Intel Corp.; various orders for American computer manufacturers Dell and Hewlett-Packard; motherboards for UK computer manufacturer Zoostorm; the PlayStation 2 and PlayStation 3 for Sony; the Wii for Nintendo; the Xbox 360 for Microsoft, cell phones for Motorola, the Amazon Kindle, and Cisco equipment. [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foxconn](wikipedia)[/url]

Odds are you're using a number of Foxconn products yourself.

ennir

Nope, no cell phone, no ipod, no ipad, no playstation, no Apple products, no Zoostorm, no Hewlett-Packard, no......which is not to say that I consider myself "pure" as I recognize that we are all in this tangle together but I do make certain choices and they include not buying into having to have the latest toys. 

Many years ago I saw a movie and now I can't even recall exactly what movie it was but I do recall that I was left with the question of what do things cost, really cost, and since then that has been a guiding prinicple in my choices.

RosaL

ennir wrote:

Nope, no cell phone, no ipod, no ipad, no playstation, no Apple products, no Zoostorm, no Hewlett-Packard, no......which is not to say that I consider myself "pure" as I recognize that we are all in this tangle together but I do make certain choices and they include not buying into having to have the latest toys. 

What kind of logicboard do you have in your computer? Anything from intel perhaps? In any case, I meant "you", plural. 

My "toys" are used mostly for work. And for reading and studying. (I live in an isolated area, nowhere near a half decent bookstore or library.) I, too, make choices. There are things I don't buy and things I don't do. Quite a few, actually. They are probably different from yours. Given that - as you say - purity is impossible and the best we can do is make "certain choices" (when it comes to buying stuff) maybe we shouldn't condemn people for not making exactly the same ones we do. 

E.Tamaran

ennir wrote:

And Rabble gives away Apple products and uses the Royal Bank, wow, I find myself jarred by the incongruity of a "progressive" board supporting those who are not progressive at all.

And Rabble's servers are located in the USA. (but we mustn't speak of it)

No Yards No Yards's picture

Then I assume you weren't around a few years ago when rabble ran into trouble for firing one of its employees via voice mail (or some such "progressive" manner,) and management acted like compete BP CEO asses.

Don't ever assume that just because rabble is presented as a progressive forum that this means that it always follows progressive business practices.

ennir

No Yards wrote:

Then I assume you weren't around a few years ago when rabble ran into trouble for firing one of its employees via voice mail (or some such "progressive" manner,) and management acted like compete BP CEO asses.

Don't ever assume that just because rabble is presented as a progressive forum that this means that it always follows progressive business practices.

I was around then and it did occur to me as I read that Rabble gives away Apple products, has a connection to the Royal Bank and uses servers based in U.S. that it was consistent with firing a moderator by email, which I think was the"progressive"means used.

 

 

Doug
Agent666

"Does it really matter where it is made?"

The 'People's' Republic of China is a brutally-authoritarian, racist and corruption-ridden dictatorship, with the worlds' highest rate of executions. There is zero religious, or political freedom. Really, the term 'fascist' works here, as the Han majority leaders rule the country with an iron fist and sense of racial superiority. Much of the industrial output of 'Communist' China comes out of slave labour camps. China keeps the yuan absurdly-undervalued, ensuring the compeditive advantage of its products notwithstanding labour costs. Canada has lost a great deal of its manufacturing jobs to China, even on Canadian soil (that Esquimalt crane project). Really, there should be import duties on Chinese goods, but Canada's politicians, like Bob Rae and Jean Chretien, have been too busy cultivating business ties with that dictatorship. Even the NDP refuses to get involved: Jack Layton will whine about a trade agreement with Colombia, but won't touch the matter of trade with a vicious dictatorship that's stolen perhaps hundreds of thousands of Canadian manufacturing jobs. Layton is too busy schmoozing with expat business leaders in the Chinese community, trolling for votes. (When the Ironworkers Union pleaded with the NDP to get involved in that Esquimalt issue, Layton ignored them.) China also supports, financially and militarilly, the Janjaweed militia in Sudan, as part of its neo-imperialist (oil, minerals, farmland) policy in Africa. All of you people concerned about gun violence should also realize that those AK-47 and Sig handgun clones, as well as shotguns used by drug gangs here in Canada come from China's Norinco Industries, mostly smuggled on container ships.

When Apartheid was in force, Canada rightfully boycotted trade with and investment in South Africa. The PRC is no better than Apartheid South Africa: a nasty dictatorship of one 'superior' race, executing people left and right, employing slave labour and fighting imperial wars in Africa. It really does matter where you buy stuff from, and it also matters if we keep losing manufacturing jobs to China.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Doug

I suppose you could see this coming - it looks like using vast quantities of labour in China has just got too expensive. Many fewer employees in Taiwan (that won't kill themselves as often, I suppose) supported by automation is looking better.

 

Foxconn – the electronics manufacturer whose clients include Apple, Dell and HP – is on the verge of closing its mainland China operations in a massive restructuring effort that could see 800,000 workers lose their jobs.

Fidel

I think Taiwan was neck and neck with South Korea for dubious distinction of longest work week in the world a few years ago. They've used former military officers in those countries to bark orders at workers, and who are penned up in concentration camp-like conditions with ten or more jammed together in company housing etc. Our corporate jackals consider us worthless and weak compared to captive labour forces in those countries.

Catchfire Catchfire's picture

Is the iPhone polluting China?

Quote:
Announcing the iPhone4 at the WWDC conference earlier this month, Apple CEO Steve Jobs said, "it's a major jump from the original models. This is undoubtedly the most beautiful and sophisticated product I have created."

However in sharp contrast with this high-profile release, Apple has been silent about questions regarding their supply chain's heavy metal pollution. On April 16, 2010, 34 Chinese environmental organizations, including Friends of Nature, the Institute of Public and Environmental Affairs, and Green Beagle, questioned heavy metal pollution in a letter sent to CEO Steve Jobs. 50 days have passed, and though the significant problems with the IT industry's violations of heavy metals standards have been reported through media, Apple has not given a word in response.

iPhone4 is sold in the US, Europe and elsewhere, but it was assembled in China. As the world's center for the processing of IT products, China's environment is paying the price. Printed Circuit Board (PCB) and battery power production especially create heavy metal pollution and has particularly serious damage and consequences. To promote the development of a true shift to green business behavior, 34 environmental NGOs conducted research and found data on some heavily polluting suppliers to IT brands. Then they made communications on this issue with 29 IT brands including Apple. Now 50 days has passed and Apple, with all its high-profile environmental commitment, is one of the 8 companies who did not respond.